On 1/3/24 09:50, Levi C. Maaia, K6LCM wrote:
Anyway, I know that LED drivers can be a source of RF noise, especially cheap ones that use PWM to dim the light from LEDs. The one that came with this piece was visibly “dirty” to the point that I swear that I could see the flicker at certain brightness settings. I put my portable scope on the DC LED dimmer/driver output and it was very ugly.
They are pretty much all PWM. Resistive dimmers are horribly inefficient.
I decided to do some research and see what I could learn about PWM and LEDs. Turns out that the frequency at which these drivers pulse the light varies from model to model with some pulsing the light on and off at as slow a frequency as ~200 Hz. Apparently that was enough for be to perceive flicker. I found another unit that was more that three times faster (~600Hz) and swapped it in. The flicker went away and the picture on the scope looks a lot cleaner now. In the attached video I show the “clean" output, then the “dirty" output. I can’t figure out how the dirty output manages to even dim the light. It barely budges off of 12 volts while the clean driver has nice, neat square pulses.
The "dirty" one is likely just filtered with a capacitor across the output. LEDs are current driven. If the series LED string has a forward voltage drop of just under 12 volts and there's a fat capacitor across the output of the PWM dimmer it will look like 12 volts with a bit of ripple at the switching frequency on a scope. Ripple will be more evident at lower brightness levels. While you've labeled it "dirty" it's likely going to be cleaner from an RF standpoint than driving the LEDs with square waves over a length of wire that can and will act as an antenna.
I suspect that the flicker is an artifact of the dimmer control circuitry missing pulses at certain brightness levels. Maybe poor line-side filtering causing power line "beating" with the internal oscillator at particular brightness levels.
200 hertz isn't going to produce visible flicker. Old-school TVs are 30 hertz with interlace that makes it effectively 60. 35-mm movies at theaters are/were 24 hertz, usually with a shutter that mimics 48 hertz to reduce flicker. Even many gaming monitors are 120 hertz or less. The fact that it only flickers at certain brightness levels says that the 200 hertz refresh rate isn't the cause of the flicker.
I didn’t notice any noise on the ham bands with either, which is good. I have other LED drivers around the house that are noisier on the RF side. Maybe I’ll try swapping those out.
I think you'll find that the squarewave version is noisier. Try the low end of the AM broadcast band.